I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the time line
right. It would fit better if one of the characters could lie about his age
to enlist in WWII, but I can only remember reading about this happening in
WWI.
Is it plausable to have the character lie about his age and enlist in WWII?
BTW, this bit of the play is inspired by a memorial board in our theatre
which lists all the men who died in 'The Great War' from that area. One of
the names is EC Bytheway. It occurred to me that this fellow might have
entered the army under an assumed name and was killed and now is buried
without his real name being on his grave.
This possibility seemed particularly sad to me, but it must have happened
many times.
Mekon
D. Spencer Hines - 28 Jan 2006 01:39 GMT
Yes.
I know several who did so.
Good Men All.
DSH
>I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the time line
> right. It would fit better if one of the characters could lie about his
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> Is it plausable [sic] to have the character lie about his age and enlist
> in WWII?
cramerj58@yahoo.com - 28 Jan 2006 02:31 GMT
Joetheone - 28 Jan 2006 18:26 GMT
> >I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the time line
> > right. It would fit better if one of the characters could lie about his
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> > Is it plausable [sic] to have the character lie about his age and enlist
> > in WWII?
I think Audie Murphy did that.
Jack Linthicum - 28 Jan 2006 18:30 GMT
> > >I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the time
> line
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>
> I think Audie Murphy did that.
Well, my brother-in-law did just that and rode around in ships until
Iwo and caught some sh.t there. He still carries pieces of whatever hit
him.
D. Spencer Hines - 28 Jan 2006 18:41 GMT
Hilarious!
"He's" building his plot line by cobbling together all these stories about
under-age recruits.
DSH
Jack Linthicum - 28 Jan 2006 18:52 GMT
> Hilarious!
>
> "He's" building his plot line by cobbling together all these stories about
> under-age recruits.
>
> DSH
They weren't recruits they were volunteers.
Mekon - 29 Jan 2006 01:16 GMT
> Hilarious!
>
> "He's" building his plot line by cobbling together all these stories about
> under-age recruits.
>
> DSH
No. I am not.
I just wanted my main character's grandfather to have a "history" and I
wanted it to be plausible. If the time line wasn't right I would have had to
shift the current time back twenty years.
In the plot the 'grandfather' never got over the survivor guilt of being in
a reserved occupation (coal miner) while his brother lied about his age and
was killed.
If you have a funny story about sibling rivalry - that I *can* use to add
to the plot.
I have never understood what you get out of doing this. You and I rarely
post on the same thread (most of your talk about US politics bores me to
tears) and yet you fabricate a post designed to make me look somehow
unethical. (and cross post to various unrelated groups) You seem to go out
of your way to get attention. Any attention, even negative, seems to be what
you crave, anything rather than being ignored.
I was glad to read your first post, it was on topic and added to my
knowledge of the subject. And then you post this crap.
Not so much 'hilarious as incomprehensible.
Mekon
D. Spencer Hines - 29 Jan 2006 01:42 GMT
Hilarious!
"He's" building his plot line by cobbling together all these stories about
under-age recruits.
He wants to know names and stories about Real People so he can do some
cherry-picking, cobble together a story line and sell it as a screenplay.
Hilarious!
This way he doesn't even have to pay a Research Assistant.
"He'll" -- "put AHB in the credits if it ever gets past his PC."
Fat Chance Of That...
DSH
old hoodoo - 28 Jan 2006 20:23 GMT
>>>I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the time
>
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> I think Audie Murphy did that.
A lot of youngsters did it in WWII, I think. My own ex-father in law
did that to get away from the farm in South Texas. Enlisted in 42. He
had just turned 16 on June 6, 42 and joined the Navy. Even today you
can enlist at 17 with parental consent, so he basically told his Dad it
was either to lie about his age and sign the enlistment form stating his
birthdate as 1925 rather than 1926 and allow him to join the service or
he was running away. He was sick of the farm and the war gave him an
opportunity to get away. He father was an old time "padron" type that
worked his kids like slaves. His father gave in when he realized that
Rudy was dead serious. My father in law was no softie, he had he had
been worked all his short life and was tough as nails. Apparently they
were no checking birth certificates too hard at the beginning of the
war. He may not even have had a birth certificate at that time.
We weighed 117 pounds going in, think he was 5'5" but little guys were
not as much as an oddity back then as they seem to be now. Became a
rear gunner radio operator in SBD's then flew combat in the Pacific as a
tail turret gunner in a PB4Y1
(navalized B-24D Liberator). Operated out of FuniFuni and Nukefatal.
Amazingly found a photograph of him on the net on a Island website. A
little feller but no question it was him. He was Mexican-American.
Through the photo his wife was able to find one of his old buds that was
the source of the picture. Unfortunately Rudy had just passed away.
He shot down one Jap fighter. Said it just flew across his guns and
went to pieces...didn't explode or anything that dramatic.
He also crash landed in the ocean in the "24". The crew survived except
for the pilot. They temporarily buried him in a trench dug out of the
coral but unfortunately while lowering him in, the casket flipped an
dumped the pilot into the trench.
There was a little of perplexity as to what to do, but my ex-father in
law, with the callousness of youth suggested they just leave him like
that until he was picked up to take home. An officer then ordered my
ex-father in law with another guy to go into the trench and get the
pilot out...the moral to the story is that an enlisted man should never
offer suggestions.
Additionally he had a story that is a typical story, so much that it is
a cliche. While doing anti-sub duty in an SBD (carried a depth charge)
he (now a "veteran" gunner to whom teh novelty of flying was no longer
fun) was assigned to a relatively new pilot that already had a bad
reputation for being a hot shot among the gunners. A newbie was all
excited about going on the mission and my ex-pop was glad to give him
the rear seat.
The SBD took off, the pilot put it into a steep bank and immediately
crashed it into the sea with in full view of the field. No survivors.
These stories were pried out of him over the years....he did not like to
talk about the war.
He did get exited though when an SBD (a real SBD, either owed by the CAF
or Lone Star Aviation) flew into our area at an airshow. I took him out
to see it and for a short while he was talkative about the war, then
clammed up the next day.
There was a TV movie about the true story of a big 12 year old (I think
Ricky Schroeder played him)that enlisted and served in combat on the
Salt Lake City at Guadacanal. Kids name was Calvin Graham. That one
caused a negative stir I think when Graham, who got the purple heart was
found out. I don't recall hardly anything of the film.
Jack Linthicum - 28 Jan 2006 20:39 GMT
> >>>I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the time
> >
[quoted text clipped - 73 lines]
> caused a negative stir I think when Graham, who got the purple heart was
> found out. I don't recall hardly anything of the film.
Here is the Wikipedia article on Graham,
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calvin_Graham
The Navaho code talkers kind of flew both ways, underage and over age.
These guys organize
Veterans of Underage Military Service (VUMS) - Did you serve in the
military at least one day while younger than 17 years or in the
Merchant Marine younger than 16 years? Contact: R. Thorpe, 6616 E. Buss
Rd., Clinton, WI 53525, (608) 676-4925, e-mail:
bdavidson1110@earthlink.net.
http://ddiekman.tripod.com/id51.html
A current display at the Navy Memorial showcases underage World War II
veterans.
The display includes Calvin Graham, the youngest combat veteran of the
war.
He earned a Bronze Star for heroism and a Purple Heart for shrapnel
wounds.
Another underage Texan was Bobbie Lee Pettit, who enlisted in 1942 at
age 13, and was a first class petty officer by war's end.
He participated in six cruises to the Pacific theater and five major
campaigns.
Because of his age he also was denied an honorable discharge and GI
benefits after the war.
His Congressman intervened and convinced the Navy to give him an
honorable discharge, enabling him to fulfill his high school and
college dreams.
Jackson Hoffler from North Carolina was the youngest combat sailor in
the Normandy invasion.
At age 15 he was a gunner on a landing craft (LCVP), which carried
troops and supplies to the beach all day June 6, and carried the
wounded back to the ship.
When his LCVP was sunk the next day, Jackson joined the Beach
Battalion. For the next month he helped move supplies across the beach,
and was wounded twice during that time.
hippo - 28 Jan 2006 06:24 GMT
"Mekon" wrote in message
>I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the time line
> right. It would fit better if one of the characters could lie about his
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
> This possibility seemed particularly sad to me, but it must have happened
> many times.
It was quite common on this side of the pond in WWII, but I'm sure just how.
Forged or altered documents most likely. There were no picture IDs in those
days. -the Troll
F. Frederick Skitty - 28 Jan 2006 11:01 GMT
> I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the time line
> right. It would fit better if one of the characters could lie about his age
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
> Mekon
My aunt's ex-husband enlisted in the US Army Air Force aged 15. WW2 was
practically over at the time however. He served 25 years in total.
Not sure it was as easy to lie in the UK at the time.
William Black - 28 Jan 2006 11:09 GMT
> My aunt's ex-husband enlisted in the US Army Air Force aged 15. WW2 was
> practically over at the time however. He served 25 years in total.
>
> Not sure it was as easy to lie in the UK at the time.
Not easy at all.
Everyone of military age was required to register in about 1936
People were asked not to volunteer, although some did.
There had been a lot of trouble about under age people enlisting in WWI,
and also people from the same community joining the same unit together,
which caused problems when those units took heavy losses and so they
deliberately changed things.

Signature
William Black
I've seen things you people wouldn't believe.
Barbeques on fire by the chalets past the castle headland
I watched the gift shops glitter in the darkness off the Newborough gate
All these moments will be lost in time, like icecream on the beach
Time for tea.
Don Phillipson - 28 Jan 2006 12:16 GMT
> I am working on a new play . . .
> Is it plausable to have the character lie about his age and enlist in WWII?
It depends on the country: e.g. Britain had issued "identity
cards" before the outbreak of WW2, thus had some sort of
a national list of citizens (including age) but the USA did not
(but required all men aged X to Y to "regisiter for the draft.")
Neither system antedated WW1 in either country.
Most countries enlisted teenagers under age X if they had their
parents' written permission: but could detect under-age
volunteers (boys aged X-1 who claimed to be X+1) only if the
enlistment process included independent documentary
verification of their actual age. Notoriously many boys aged
15 or 16 enlisted in WW1 (including my Uncle Ted.) Most
were detected before their battalions went into combat, but
a few actually fought when that young.

Signature
Don Phillipson
Carlsbad Springs
(Ottawa, Canada)
Andrew Chaplin - 28 Jan 2006 12:44 GMT
> I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the time line
> right. It would fit better if one of the characters could lie about his age
> to enlist in WWII, but I can only remember reading about this happening in
> WWI.
>
> Is it plausable to have the character lie about his age and enlist in WWII?
Quite. There are dead relatives' identities one might use, like the
elder brother who died at the age of 3 or some such. It helps if you
can find a co-operative official who can provide the paperwork or
vouch for you. In rural areas where births may have gone unregistered,
late registration with an incorrect date.
I know a man who joined the Canadian Forces in 1975 at the age of 15
with the help of a clergyman. He was from Quebec where the province
did not issue birth certificates until the 1980s, they relied on
baptismal certificates produced by parishes.
> BTW, this bit of the play is inspired by a memorial board in our theatre
> which lists all the men who died in 'The Great War' from that area. One of
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> This possibility seemed particularly sad to me, but it must have happened
> many times.
There are 15 people named "Bytheway" in the Commonwealth war graves
database (http://www.cwgc.org) but no one with the initials E.C. nor
any Australians among them.

Signature
Andrew Chaplin
SIT MIHI GLADIUS SICUT SANCTO MARTINO
(If you're going to e-mail me, you'll have to get "yourfinger." out.)
Mekon - 28 Jan 2006 13:08 GMT
(snip)
> There are 15 people named "Bytheway" in the Commonwealth war graves
> database (http://www.cwgc.org) but no one with the initials E.C. nor
> any Australians among them.
He is on the memorial board and yet not on the honour roll at the Australian
War Memorial (www.awm.gov.au ) I have written to them pointing out this
discrepancy. I don't know how it came about. Maybe he died later of wounds
and the central records were not informed. He wasn't married - his next of
kin was his mother. So maybe as there was no widow to support the AWM wasn't
required to be notified.
Mekon
John Dean - 28 Jan 2006 14:39 GMT
> I am working on a new play and am having some trouble getting the
> time line right. It would fit better if one of the characters could
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> Is it plausable to have the character lie about his age and enlist in
> WWII?
Absolutely
Here's one of our famous liars, Patrick Moore:
http://www.zone-sf.com/patrickmoore.html
"And soon after, Patrick achieved the unique distinction of being
elected to the British Astronomical Association while still a schoolboy.
However, the obvious academic future, which could have followed, was
denied by the intervention of a hereditary heart problem, preventing him
taking up a place at Eton. So instead he lied about his age and cheated
on the medical to join-up for the RAF at 16, in time to use star-charts
to fly as a Bomber Navigator during World War II. But this early
military service also had the unfortunate side effect of preventing him
taking a promised place at Cambridge. Also his sweetheart was killed "in
the wrong place at the wrong time," which is why he never married."
Less famous but equally gallant - Jack Banks, dead at 16 :
http://archive.thisislancashire.co.uk/2005/04/04/438002.html
"Jack Banks joined the Home Guard at 14 years old - a crack shot who was
very keen to join the army. He lied about his age and enlisted in the
Durham Light Infantry when he was only 15. He survived the Normandy
beaches but was killed a few weeks later on July 21, 1944 in the advance
to take Bayeux."
Plenty more examples for the tireless Googleer

Signature
John Dean
Oxford
Mekon - 29 Jan 2006 01:22 GMT
Thanks all. I'll put AHB in the credits if it ever gets past my PC.
:)
Mekon