Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion Groups
General
General TopicsAncient HistoryMedieval PeriodBritish HistoryWhat IfArchaeology
War History
War HistoryWorld War IIUS Civil War
HistoryKB.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

History Forum / General / British History / June 2007



Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Gates Says Iraq Troop Surge Only Starting To Bite

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
D. Spencer Hines - 16 Jun 2007 19:11 GMT
A realistic and cogent interim status report from Bob Gates, David Petraeus
and Ryan Crocker.

Far, far different from the Chicken Little Hysterical Defeatist Ramblings of
Gans and other lesser pogues without the law in these precincts -- including
Horsellman Rarebit....

Singularly devoid of Bush Derangement Syndrome as well.

DSH

Lux et Veritas et Libertas
------------------------------------------------------------------

Gates says Iraq troop surge only starting to bite

by Jim Mannion Jun 16, 2007

Agence France Presse

US Defence Secretary Robert Gates said Saturday that a troop surge in Iraq
is only starting to have its full impact and that it is too soon to tell
whether conditions will be ripe by September for decisions on US force
levels.

The US commander in Iraq, General David Petraeus, said that the latest troop
reinforcements to arrive in theatre had enabled the military to begin major
operations against Al-Qaeda rear-bases outside the capital.

Excellent!  Critically Important.  Go After The Hives. -- DSH

"While I indicated yesterday that I think we'll see some trends and be able
to point in some directions by September, the full impact of the surge is
really just beginning to be felt," Gates said.

Gates has held out the possibility of US troop reductions if the surge
succeeds in calming a wave of sectarian violence in Baghdad by September,
but he was more cautious Saturday during a brief unannounced visit to
Baghdad.

"I actually think it is premature to answer that question or make that
judgement," he told reporters.

"I think we have to wait and see where we are in September to see what
follows the report that the ambassador and the general turn in."

Petraeus and US ambassador Ryan Crocker are supposed to report to a
sceptical Congress in September on whether the surge is working or whether
an alternative strategy is needed.

Gates was to meet Prime Minister Nuri al-Maliki later to press for more
rapid progress by his Shiite-led government in reaching out to the
disenchanted Sunni former elite.

He is the third senior US official to deliver the same message over the past
week, following Deputy Defence Secretary John Negroponte, the former US
ambassador, and Admiral William Fallon, commander of US forces in the Middle
East.

Excellent!  Fox Fallon has stepped into the Grand Strategy role for which he
was chosen. -- DSH

"We are pressing hard on those (reconciliation benchmarks)," said the US
ambassador, who joined Gates and Petraeus at a news conference.

Ryan Crocker, said ambassador, is an excellent man too -- adding just the
right talents to the Leadership mix. -- DSH

"The Iraqi government has been pushing itself.  The progress has been
frustratingly slow.

Indeed. -- DSH

"We will see where we are by September. We will report at that time honestly
as to what has been achieved and what hasn't," said Crocker.

Gates, who visited troops at a joint security post in Baghdad, said there
had been successes in reducing violence in Anbar province west of the
capital, although security had deteriorated in Diyala province to its north.

"In terms of the security situation, as I say we've got two months, three
months to go. There are some positive trends, there are some negative
trends," he said.

Petraeus said it was possible to make progress over the next few months.

"And then we'll see how long we'll sustain the surge, and how long we can
sustain the surge, because those considerations enter into it as well."

Indeed.  And if the DEFEATISTS at HOME pull the plug, as they did in the
Vietnam War, the entire Middle East will be in deep kimchee. -- DSH

Asked whether he had enough troops, Petraeus said: "There has never been a
military commander in history who would not like to have more of something
or other.

"The fact is frankly we have all that our country is going to provide us in
terms of combat forces. That is really it right now between this theatre and
Afghanistan."

US troops levels in Iraq swelled to 155,000 over the past week as the last
of five additional combat brigades deployed, US commanders said.

Petraeus said "fairly large coordinated offensive operations" had been
launched against Al-Qaeda in areas outside Baghdad in the previous 24 hours.

Excellent!  Exterminate most -- take a few prisoners for INTERROGATION.  Let
the Iraqis do most of the interrogations of those captured who are not of
particular interest to the Americans -- and don't ask the Iraqis about their
methods. -- DSH

"We have been doing what we might be calling shaping operations in a lot of
these areas, doing intelligence gathering, putting in some special
operators, going in but then coming out," he said.

SHAPE, DESTROY, COOPT, BUILD, HOLD. -- DSH

"And now for the first time are we going to some key areas in the belt from
which Al-Qaeda has sallied forth with car bombs and additional fighters and
so forth."
-------------------------------

DSH

Semper Fidelis
D. Spencer Hines - 16 Jun 2007 20:48 GMT
More in the same vein.

DSH
---------------------------------------------

US Launches New Offensive in Iraq

16 June 2007

By LOLITA C. BALDOR
Associated Press Writer

     BAGHDAD (AP) - The U.S. military, which just days ago completed its
latest troop buildup in Iraq, has launched a large offensive operation in
several al-Qaida strongholds around Baghdad, the top U.S. commander said
Saturday.

     Gen. David Petraeus said the operation began in the last 24 hours and
will put forces into key areas surrounding Baghdad that, according to
intelligence, al-Qaida is using to base some of its car bomb operations.

Excellent!  Exterminate most -- take a few prisoners for INTERROGATION.  Let
the Iraqis do most of the interrogations of those captured who are not of
particular interest to the Americans -- and don't ask the Iraqis about their
methods. -- DSH

     Petraeus, who met with Defense Secretary Robert Gates at a morning
breakfast, also said that he doesn't have all the American troops he might
want, but he knows he's got all he's going to get.

     "There's never been a military commander in history who wouldn't like
to have more of something or other—that characterizes all of us here," he
told reporters traveling with Gates. "The fact is frankly that we have all
that our country is going to provide us in terms of combat forces. That is
really it right now."

     He said the buildup of nearly 30,000 additional forces that has just
been completed allowed him to launch the latest assault. The move, he said,
is allowing him to send operations for the first time into "a number of
areas around Baghdad, in particular to go into areas that were sanctuaries
in the past of al-Qaida."

They must not be allowed any sanctuaries. -- DSH

     American and Iraqi forces have absolute control over only 40 percent
of the capital, according to U.S. officials.

     He said: "Our job now, frankly, along with the job of our Iraqi
counterparts ... is to do everything that we can with the additional forces
that we have."

     Underscoring the challenges ahead, Gates arrival Friday night for his
unannounced visit, brought him to a city all but shut down by a security
lockdown. Iraqi leaders imposed a strict curfew this week after a bombing of
an important shrine north of the city.

Reminds me of my time in Saigon. -- DSH

     It is Gates' fourth trip to Iraq since he took over the Defense
Department last December. He was meeting with military and political leaders
to assess progress, and to continue to urge the Iraqi government to move
more quickly toward reconciliation and stabilizing their country.

     Petraeus provided few details of the new offensive, but said he
believes it will help the military make some progress in Iraq, where the war
is in its fifth year and U.S. casualties have surpassed 3,500.

Petraeus SHOULD be providing only a VERY few DETAILS at this point. -- DSH

     Gates and his military leaders are under intense pressure from
Congress and the American public to begin to show real progress in Iraq so
that troop withdrawals can start.

     There are currently about 155,000 U.S. troops in Iraq.

     At the same time, Gates and U.S. Ambassador Ryan Crocker expressed
continuing frustration with the lack of political progress by the Iraqis to
meet a number of benchmarks set by the U.S., including oil revenue-sharing
legislation and political reconciliation.

     "We are pressing hard on those," said Crocker. "The Iraqi government
is pressing itself. Progress has been frustratingly slow. We will see where
we are by September."

Indeed. -- DSH

     After a meeting with Gates, Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki's office
said he had told the U.S. defense secretary Iraqi leaders are making
"persistent efforts" and have "a chance" to achieve national political
reconciliation.

     Al-Maliki also pointed out that Iraqi security forces generally headed
off any greater explosion of Shiite-Sunni sectarian violence in Iraq after
last Wednesday's bombing at the holy Shiite shrine of al-Askariya in the
city of Samarra, his office said.

     During his visit, Gates also stopped by the al-Madain Joint Security
Station Saturday morning in southeast Baghdad, traveling under tight
security, and wearing body armor. His helicopter sent up a cloud of dust as
it set down in the rectangular, walled station in the largely Shiite enclave
of Karada, a relatively stable area of the city.

     Gates heard from both Iraqi and U.S. military officials, who talked
about the effort to put as many as 60 of the security outposts in the
Baghdad region. There are about 27 joint security stations, which are
staffed by Iraqi police and army soldiers as well as U.S. troops. And there
are about the same number of smaller combat outposts.

     Col. Jeffrey Bannister, commander of the 2nd Brigade, 2nd Infantry
Division which has forces at the station, said the facility was a model for
Baghdad and "has a very good fusion effect amongst the Iraqis."

     He added, however, that his troops have faced a lot of newer armor-
piercing roadside bombs. "We are at the tip of the spear for that," he told
reporters who traveled to the station with Gates.

     Gates thanked the Iraqi forces there for their service and expressed
sympathy for those who have been wounded and killed. "They are serving the
interests of the Iraqi people," Gates said.

     Gates is the third top U.S. official to travel to Baghdad this week to
press the Iraqi government to move more quickly toward political
reconciliation and other vital reforms that many see as critical to putting
a cap on the violence.

     The top U.S. commander in the Middle East, Adm. William Fallon carried
that message to the Iraqis last weekend, and John Negroponte, the No. 2
State Department official, reinforced it in a visit midweek.

     Gates also was cautious in his assessment of the progress in the war.
He's to give Congress an update next month, and a full review in September,
of how well the buildup ordered by President Bush has worked.

     "It remains to be seen how much progress will be made over the course
of the next two or three months," Gates said, adding "There are some
positive trends, there are some negative trends."
--------------------------------------------------------------

Bingo!

A far cry from the line pedaled by the Chicken Little Hysterical Defeatist
Ramblings of Gans and other lesser pogues without the law in these
precincts -- including Horsellman Rarebit....

Singularly devoid of Bush Derangement Syndrome as well.

SHAPE, DESTROY, COOPT, BUILD, HOLD.

DSH

Lux et Veritas et Libertas
dapra - 17 Jun 2007 00:21 GMT
> A realistic and cogent interim status report from Bob Gates, David Petraeus
> and Ryan Crocker.
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>
> Gates says Iraq troop surge only starting to bite

Yes, it starts biting Bush in the butt. But no biting will deter him
from trying of get the oil. Hang him in The Hague would be the only way
to cure him.
David E. Powell - 17 Jun 2007 05:05 GMT
> > A realistic and cogent interim status report from Bob Gates, David Petraeus
> > and Ryan Crocker.
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> from trying of get the oil. Hang him in The Hague would be the only way
> to cure him

Um, dude... if Bush wanted the oil in Iraq so bad, why do the Iraqis
have it and not the US? Oh wait, because your argument is a
meaningless canard that you know to be false. OK. See you.
dapra - 18 Jun 2007 16:11 GMT
>>>A realistic and cogent interim status report from Bob Gates, David Petraeus
>>>and Ryan Crocker.
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
> Um, dude... if Bush wanted the oil in Iraq so bad, why do the Iraqis
> have it and not the US?

One can't just stash the loot into a getaway car. Oil fields are
difficult to transport to Texas.

Bush should have attacked Switzerland. It had no more or less relation
to Al qaeda, than Iraq. But probably he could have generated just as
many or even more 'terrorists'. One of the real impetus behind the
invasion. Imagine all the 'terrorists' infiltrating from Germany,
France, Italy. And of course the loot would have been easily
transferable. Just empty the banks vaults, and ship the gold to Crawford.

One may say the oil fields of Iraq are a lot more valuable, and it gives
the advantage to the Bush regime to strangle the world economy at will.
That's true too. Maybe that's why, they attacked Iraq not Switzerland,
in spite of the difficulty  taking possessions of the loot.

>Oh wait, because your argument is a
> meaningless canard that you know to be false. OK. See you.
Tiglath - 17 Jun 2007 06:21 GMT
>A realistic and cogent interim status report from Bob Gates, David Petraeus
>and Ryan Crocker.

>  it is too soon to tell whether conditions will be ripe by September for
> decisions on US force levels.

Translation:  The Surge is not working.

Trust Mr. Hines bringing a declaration of lack of results as "encouraging
signs."

As if we had not seen those before.

The hawks war shares are penny stocks and lining up on the chute that will
take them to Enron stock level.

Mr. Hines is just bracing himself.

Mark my words:   When September comes, Mr. Hines will still be saying and
quoting people saying that more time is needed because things are beginning
to jell, almost.  And that we shouldn't give up when things are going well,
well almost.

We've seen it all before.

Mr. Hines was taught to never surrender, but he missed the class after that
when exceptions were cited.   Hence, Mr. Hines will walk into a cannonade, a
fusillade, and ambuscade, or more like it, into a dilluvium of cream pies,
as he does here often, figuratively, and proudly wear on his face more egg
than is is becoming to an officer, without compunction.

He surely has come up a cropper on Iraq --  four and and a half years AND
counting.

His brave act in the face of adversity shows he is as stubborn as Bush, but
little else.
Adam Whyte-Settlar - 17 Jun 2007 08:57 GMT
> We've seen it all before.
>
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> of cream pies, as he does here often, figuratively, and proudly wear on
> his face more egg than is is becoming to an officer...

Quite - I'm sure there are times when he must really miss the catering
corps.
William Black - 17 Jun 2007 10:14 GMT
>> We've seen it all before.
>>
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> Quite - I'm sure there are times when he must really miss the catering
> corps.

The Catering corps!

They'd never be daft enough to let him near food preparation,  too many
would die...

He was a housing officer.

Signature

William Black

I've seen things you people wouldn't believe.
Barbeques on fire by the chalets past the castle headland
I watched the gift shops glitter in the darkness off the Newborough gate
All these moments will be lost in time,  like icecream on the beach
Time for tea.

La N - 17 Jun 2007 14:11 GMT
>>> We've seen it all before.
>>>
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
>
> He was a housing officer.

What does a housing officer do?  Check that everybody is in by curfew and
that the lights are turned out by 9 p.m.?

- nilita
William Black - 17 Jun 2007 14:55 GMT
>>>> We've seen it all before.
>>>>
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
> What does a housing officer do?  Check that everybody is in by curfew and
> that the lights are turned out by 9 p.m.?

Erm...

No...

As far as anyone can find out he sits in an office and acts as the
supervisor for the vanishingly small number of senior NCOs who supervise the
contactors who do the actual work and sign the tickets that authorise
payments.

No skills of any type required...

Just the ability to report on senior men who are coasting to retirement and
also to be reasonably honest  or, at least,  too stupid to be crooked...

Anyway,  back to the naval career of Lt Cdr David S Hines USN (retired)

He joined the US Navy because his dad was an admiral.  He had taken an
undergraduate degree in politics and the Russian language,  or some such
useless combination, that fitted a person only for service in the Cold War,
so long as it lasted,  and so ended up on the fringes of the intelligence
community.

As far as anyone can find out Hines was some sort of junior intelligence
manager at a US base in Japan who upset everyone who came into professional
contact with him but didn't actually screw up badly enough to get sacked,
although reports indicate he was a laughing stock and was never,  ever,
allowed anywhere near anything important.

Then,  one day, he then disagreed with a 'three star',  and refused to back
down.

He turned out to be wrong...

(No surprises there...)

He was then promptly 'moved sideways' to a job where he couldn't do any more
harm but could serve out his days to his pension without actually coming
into contact with anything that could possibly be even remotely connected
with operations in any form, and well away from any general officers...

The job was Housing Officer at Pearl Harbour...

Later on,  after retirement,  he seems to have taught for a single term at
the University of Hawaii and operated some sort of property company, for a
very short time indeed...

Further details,  from anyone, would be appreciated.

Signature

William Black

I've seen things you people wouldn't believe.
Barbeques on fire by the chalets past the castle headland
I watched the gift shops glitter in the darkness off the Newborough gate
All these moments will be lost in time,  like icecream on the beach
Time for tea.

Jack Linthicum - 17 Jun 2007 15:07 GMT
On Jun 17, 9:55 am, "William Black" <william.bl...@hotmail.co.uk>
wrote:

> >>>> We've seen it all before.
>
[quoted text clipped - 73 lines]
> All these moments will be lost in time,  like icecream on the beach
> Time for tea.

An earlier effort http://www.historykb.com/Uwe/Forum.aspx/general-history/39/D-Spencer-HInes-FAQ
http://archiver.rootsweb.com/th/read/GEN-MEDIEVAL/2005-07/1122667123

and sequential chatter on that thread.

Wife's name is Kuniko, try the 1968-9 Who's Who for Wellington T.
Hines, there are secrets there.
James Hogg - 19 Jun 2007 17:05 GMT
>On Jun 17, 9:55 am, "William Black" <william.bl...@hotmail.co.uk>
>wrote:
[quoted text clipped - 79 lines]
>An earlier effort http://www.historykb.com/Uwe/Forum.aspx/general-history/39/D-Spencer-HInes-FAQ
>http://archiver.rootsweb.com/th/read/GEN-MEDIEVAL/2005-07/1122667123

Here's a slightly more postive testimonial (but it shows that DSH has
always been a controversial character):

"You see, despite the buffoonery you saw and heard tonight, Commander
Hines is not a bad guy. He's just the 'Boss' for a large segment of
our personnel, and as the boss, he is of course a big target. He's
also big enough to be a really good sport. Thanks for that to [sic],
Commander."

That's from http://akkingfish.homestead.com/files/bradley.html

And don't forget my own poetic tribute to Hines and his ancestors:
http://tinyurl.com/38db34

James
Paul J Gans - 18 Jun 2007 18:11 GMT
In alt.history.british William Black <william.black@hotmail.co.uk> wrote:

>>>>> We've seen it all before.
>>>>>
[quoted text clipped - 16 lines]
>> What does a housing officer do?  Check that everybody is in by curfew and
>> that the lights are turned out by 9 p.m.?

>Erm...

>No...

>As far as anyone can find out he sits in an office and acts as the
>supervisor for the vanishingly small number of senior NCOs who supervise the
>contactors who do the actual work and sign the tickets that authorise
>payments.

>No skills of any type required...

>Just the ability to report on senior men who are coasting to retirement and
>also to be reasonably honest  or, at least,  too stupid to be crooked...

>Anyway,  back to the naval career of Lt Cdr David S Hines USN (retired)

>He joined the US Navy because his dad was an admiral.  He had taken an
>undergraduate degree in politics and the Russian language,  or some such
>useless combination, that fitted a person only for service in the Cold War,
>so long as it lasted,  and so ended up on the fringes of the intelligence
>community.

>As far as anyone can find out Hines was some sort of junior intelligence
>manager at a US base in Japan who upset everyone who came into professional
>contact with him but didn't actually screw up badly enough to get sacked,
>although reports indicate he was a laughing stock and was never,  ever,
>allowed anywhere near anything important.

>Then,  one day, he then disagreed with a 'three star',  and refused to back
>down.

>He turned out to be wrong...

>(No surprises there...)

>He was then promptly 'moved sideways' to a job where he couldn't do any more
>harm but could serve out his days to his pension without actually coming
>into contact with anything that could possibly be even remotely connected
>with operations in any form, and well away from any general officers...

>The job was Housing Officer at Pearl Harbour...

>Later on,  after retirement,  he seems to have taught for a single term at
>the University of Hawaii and operated some sort of property company, for a
>very short time indeed...

>Further details,  from anyone, would be appreciated.

I believe that he picked up two Master's degrees along
the way.  And was stationed in Washington for a while.

Signature

  --- Paul J. Gans

J Antero - 18 Jun 2007 19:05 GMT
>>The job was Housing Officer at Pearl Harbour...
>
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> I believe that he picked up two Master's degrees along
> the way.  And was stationed in Washington for a while.

If that's true, it just makes the whole Hines phenomenon more disturbing.

Advanced degrees imply a certain degree of intelligence and independent
thinking.  Yet, all he does is   regurgitate transparent propaganda
editorials.
a.spencer3 - 19 Jun 2007 09:18 GMT
> In alt.history.british William Black <william.black@hotmail.co.uk> wrote:
>
[quoted text clipped - 69 lines]
> I believe that he picked up two Master's degrees along
> the way.  And was stationed in Washington for a while.

And he has a lovely, brilliant daughter, hates the fact that we knew her in
her East Coast uni days, and is rightly terrified at what she told us about
Daddy.

Surreyman
Jack Linthicum - 19 Jun 2007 12:15 GMT
> > In alt.history.british William Black <william.bl...@hotmail.co.uk> wrote:
>
[quoted text clipped - 88 lines]
>
> Surreyman

Intelligence skipped a generation?
La N - 19 Jun 2007 13:31 GMT
>> In alt.history.british William Black <william.black@hotmail.co.uk> wrote:
>>
[quoted text clipped - 92 lines]
> about
> Daddy.

And it bugs him that we know that Kuniko is very unhappily married.

- nilita
The Highlander - 19 Jun 2007 16:25 GMT
>> In alt.history.british William Black <william.black@hotmail.co.uk> wrote:
>>
[quoted text clipped - 88 lines]
>
>Surreyman

That's rather sad and unforgiveably disloyal on his daughter's part.

I still cling to my vision of him sitting in front of his computer
wearing his oversized turban with the flashing plastic diamond,
directing the world's affairs via his dollar store crystal ball.

He would do well in the north of Scotland, which is one of the world's
last outposts of oddball characters. The ravings aside, I sense that
there's still a working brain behind the bitterness.

Being the descendant of a greatgrandfather who once ripped the kilt
off a man strolling along Princes Street in Edinburgh, on the grounds
that he was wearing "the family tartan but definitely wasn't one of
us", I have a certain sympathy for the offbeat mind.

Scotland is awash with them, as witness the steady flow of inventions
and ideas from that curious and unique band of rugged individuals we
call the Scots.

The Highlander
Tilgibh smucaid air do làmhan,
togaibh a' bhratach dhubh agus
toisichibh a' geàrradh na sgòrnanan!
Adam Whyte-Settlar - 17 Jun 2007 16:44 GMT
>>> We've seen it all before.
>>>
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
>
> He was a housing officer.

So he claims - trainee dishwasher would be more appropriate to his
intelligence level.
Jack Linthicum - 18 Jun 2007 16:26 GMT
> A realistic and cogent interim status report from Bob Gates, David Petraeus
> and Ryan Crocker.

General Petraeus says the surge won't work now, in July or ever.
We are going to be in Iraq for ten years, actually he said it takes
ten years to put down an insurrection. He didn't seem to subtract the
four we have been there. The Soviet operation in Afghanistan took ten
years to fail, are we trying for a record?

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,283553,00.html
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2009 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.