Another C.P. Correction: Jasper Tudor's bastard daughter, Ellen, wife of William Gardiner, and her issue
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Douglas Richardson - 28 Aug 2007 22:39 GMT Dear Newsgroup ~
Jasper Tudor, K.G., Duke of Bedford, Earl of Pembroke (died 1495), the enigmatic uncle of King Henry VII of England, had one known illegitimate daughter, Ellen (or Helen), who became the wife of William Gardiner, Citizen and Grocer of London. Ellen and her husband, William, in turn had one known child, Thomas Gardiner, who was Prior of Tynemouth.
For evidence and particulars of the Gardiner family, see the following sources:
Gibson, A descriptive and historical guide to Tynemouth (1849): 106- 108. Memoirs Chiefly Illustrative of the Hist. & Antiqs.of Northumberland 1 (1858): 166. Benolte et al., Vis. of Sussex 1530, 1633-4 (H.S.P. 53) (1905): 122 (Owen pedigree). Broadley, Doctor Johnson and Mrs. Thrale (1910): 280-281. Chrimes, Henry VII (1972): 54, footnote 3. Muller, Stephen Gardiner and the Tudor Reaction (1970).
The first source listed above (Gibson) may be viewed at the following weblink:
http://books.google.com/books?id=ZYMHAAAAQAAJ&pg=PA106&dq=%22William+Gardiner+Ci tizen%22#PPA106,M1
Complete Peerage, 2 (1912): 73, footnote d (sub Bedford) alleges without foundation or any documentation that Jasper Tudor's daughter, Ellen (or Helen), was the mother of Stephen Gardiner, the famous Bishop of Winchester. Bishop Gardiner is known, however. to have been the son of a John Gardiner, of Bury St. Edmunds, Suffolk, possibly by a wife named Agnes [Reference: ODNB, biog. of Stephen Gardiner].
I might note that Charles Cawley's Medieval Lands database repeats this same error regarding Bishop Gardiner, and, like Complete Peerage, supplies no documentation. I assume Cawley got his information from Burke on whom he seems to rely for much of his information. The same error can be found in Burke as early as 1831. See the following weblink for Burke:
http://books.google.com/books?id=1ysWkXKSrpIC&pg=PA541&dq=Burke+Dormant+Tudor+Jasper
If anyone has furrther particulars of Ellen Tudor and William Gardiner, or their issue, I'd very much appreciate hearing from them here on the newsgroup.
Best always, Douglas Richardson, Salt Lake City, Utah ,
Lockehead - 30 Aug 2007 05:01 GMT > Dear Newsgroup ~ > [quoted text clipped - 45 lines] > Best always, Douglas Richardson, Salt Lake City, Utah > , O.K.-
I kinda started this, so I will be first to go:
All of my information (for the most part) comes from "Gardiner: Generations and Relations" by Thomas Richard Gardiner, self-published 1991. Here is what he has to say:
"Wyllyam Gardynyr, son of (father unknown) and of (mother unknown), born in 1450 in Midlands, Oxfordshire, England; died 1495 in The Bank, Surrey, England. He married in 1485, in London, England to Helen Tudor, daughter of Jasper Tudor. William Gardiner, who was born circa 1450, married Helen Tudor, first cousin to Henry VII, as found on Betham's Genealogical Table DCX in Guildhall Library, London, England. William Gardiner and his wife, Helen Tudor, resided on the south bank of the Thames River just accross from the walled city of London, prior to the establishment of any town, in an area that was then known simply as "The Bank". His magnificent home was located somewhere between the more recent towns of Bermondey and Southwalk in the county of Surrey. He also retained many of his holdings in the Midlands near Oxon Ford, now known as Oxford.
Children of Wyllyam and Heln (Tudor) Gardynyr were as follows:
2. i. Richard Gardiner, born 1486 in London, England; died 1548 in London, England. This Richard Gardiner may have been the eldest son of William Gardiner and Helen Tudor. There is no document to prove this assumption. He may have also been the father of Germain Gardiner (b. 1505) and also of Richard (b. 1507) Sargeant at Arms to Henry VIII, who was reported to have been executed for alloegedly witholding testimony in the trial of Anne Bolyn. Since I am unable to identifyn this person more fully, I have not included him and his two sons to definitely be in the line of descent from William Gardiner and Helen Tudor, although in the book, STEPHEN GARDINER AND THE TUDOR REACTION, the author mentions Germain as the nephew of Stephen. In another bit of information on Germain, he was spoken of as a cousin of Stephen, so the exact identity of these three individuals are not clear.
+3. ii. William Gardiner, born 1488
4. iii. Steven Gardiner, born 1490 in Holborn, London, England; died 12 Nov 1555 in Whitehall, Southwark, Surrey, England. See a special section on this Steven Gardiner. Steven has sometimes been named as the son of John Gardiner of Bury St. Edmunds, England but there are several things that do not fit into place on this Stephen. First of all his first name is spelled differently. The Letters and Papers of Henry VIII, in the manuscript section of the British Museum use the spelling "Steven Gardynyr" just the way Steven signed his name. The man who spelled his name Stephen was almost out of the time frame in which "Steven" was estimated by historians to have been born. But, the greatest bit of evidence supporting "Steven" vs. "Stephen" as the Bishop of Winchester, is James Betham's Genealogical Table, DCX (610) in the Guildhall Library, London, which gives Steven's parents as William Gardiner and Helen Tudor. Although the Gardiner family name has undergone a number of changes down through the ages, as have all other families, the name is being carried in the computer as Gardiner, to reduce the possibility of error in the programing of an ancestral line.
3. WIlliam Gardiner, (Wyllyam), born 1488 in London, Live awhile in Hertfordshire, England; died 1549 in The Grange, Bermondsey, Surrey, England. He married 1520, in England to Elizabeth Mitchell. There seems to be onlya alinited amount of information available on this William Gardiner, brother of Steven, Bishop of Winchester. It is believed that he may have been the presbyter at Canterbury whom Steven Gardiner stopped by to visit on one of his trips back from France which is mentioned under Steven Gardiner in this book. It was also brought to the attention of those sitting in judgement at the Excommunication trial of Steven Gardiner, that he had a brother William, and this William lived for a while in Herefordshire. William married Elizabeth Mitchell, of Yorkshire, and died in Bermondsey, Surrey. It is quite probable that William had an older brother since it is an Old English custom to name the second son after his father and the eldest son after the grandfather, which this Gardiner family has followed with remarkable consistancy down through the generations. The grandfather could come from either side of the family, as this was not followed quite as closely as in the use of the father's name. The was a Richard Gardiner, born about 1486 who was quite prominent in the London area, who may have been an older member of this family, which I have listed as a probability since I can find no other who would more easily fit the situation. He was listed in the service of Henry VIII as "Seargent at Arms"."
So, obviously, Mr. Gardiner, the author is not as astute as many on this list and jumps (no, leaps) to many conclusions. His main source is Betham's Genealogical Table. I am not familiar with this document.
Lockehead - 30 Aug 2007 05:35 GMT > > Dear Newsgroup ~ > [quoted text clipped - 135 lines] > > - Show quoted text - Another source is a wildly wonderful little book, "Blood Royal from thr time of Alexander the Great to Queen Elizabeth II" A Golden Jubilee memoir, 2952-2002 by Charles Mosley published by Smith's Peerage Limited 2002
page 208:
"2 Jasper Tudor or "of Hatfield" 1st and last Earl of Pembroke 23 Nov 1452X20 Jan 1452/3-8 Sep 1468, 1470-71 and 1485-95 and 1st and last Duke of Bedford, so cr 27 Oct 1485, KG 1459, PC 1485; b. Hatfield, herts, c. 1431; ktd 1449; Lancastrian First Battle St. Albans 22 May 1455; defeated by Edward IV Mortimer's Cross 2 or 3 Feb 1460/1 but escaped; attainted by Edward IV's parl 29 Dec 1461 and again on Edward's restoration 1471; briefly invaded Wales July 1468 in Lancastrian's cause, landing with three ships and 50 men near Harlech Castle but after sacking Denbigh was beaten off and returned to France; Ch Justice S Wales 1485; Lt Calais and Ld Lt Ireland (absentee) 1486-94; Earl Marshal 1492; took leading part inb victory of Stoke 16 Jun 1487 and invasion of France 1492; m 2 Nov 1483x7 Nov 1485 Catherine (m 3rd Sir Richard Wingfield), yst dau of 1st Earl Rivers and sis of Edward IV's w, also widow of 2nd Duke of Buckingham, and dsp by her 21 or 26 Dec 1495, when his titles expired, leaving illegitimately by an unknown woman:
1(a) Helen; m William Gardiner, a Londoner and had:
1b Stephen Gardiner; b c 1483; sec to his cousin Henry VIII 1528-33; Bp Winchester 1531-51 and 1553-22; Amb France 1535-38; promoted Henry VIII's marriage to Catherine Howard; incarcerated FLeet Prison 1547-48 and Tower London 1548-53; Ld Chllr 1553-55 (as which called by foreign diplomats 'prime minister', perhaps the earliest use of the term and one which by his ascendancy he more or less earned) and Chllr Oxford and Cambridge Us; author De Vera Obedientia ('On True Obedience') (1535) and translation of Greek New Testament; d 12 Nov 1555"
Douglas Richardson - 30 Aug 2007 06:16 GMT I very much appreciate your response. Ellen Tudor had only one son, Thomas Gardiner, who was Prior of Tynemouth, Northumberland. Ellen's husband, William Gardiner, lived in London, not Surrey. Ellen was definitely NOT the mother of Stephen Gardiner, Bishop of Winchester. This is an old error which has been repeated again and again in print (and most recently in Charles Cawley's online Medieval Lands database).
As best I can tell, your sources have combined no less than three different Gardiner families and turned them into one big happy family. Most of the information you supplied is utterly bogus, insofar as it applies to Ellen Tudor and her family.
I like James Betham's Genealogical Table, but the material is very dated.
Best always, Douglas Richardson, Salt Lake City, Utah
mjcar@btinternet.com - 30 Aug 2007 07:40 GMT > I very much appreciate your response. Ellen Tudor had only one son, I think you meant to write "only one known son"
> Thomas Gardiner, who was Prior of Tynemouth, Northumberland. Ellen's > husband, William Gardiner, lived in London, not Surrey. In fairness, it is also worth noting that differentiating Bermondsey and Southwark from London is in essence splitting hairs, as they lie within walking distance of each other and have long formed part of a single metropolis.
MA-R
Douglas Richardson - 30 Aug 2007 18:34 GMT I'll repeat this again for simple emphasis. William Gardiner, husband of Ellen Tudor, lived in London, not Surrey.
Best always, Douglas Richardson, Salt Lake City, Utah
Douglas Richardson - 30 Aug 2007 18:54 GMT Dear Newsgroup ~
The old Dicitionary of National Biography (DNB) states that Jasper Tudor "left an illegitimate daughter, Helen, who is said to have married William Gardiner, and to have been the mother of Stephen Gardiner." Part of this information is correct, and part of it is not. Jasper Tudor, Duke of Bedford (died 1495), had an illegitimate daughter, Ellen (not Helen), who married William Gardiner, as stated by the DNB. However, Ellen was not the mother of Stephen Gardiner, Bishop of Winchester. Rather, as the Visitation of Sussex correctly states, Ellen was the mother of ".... Gardiner Lord Prior of Tinmouth." [Reference: Benolte et al. Vis. of Sussex 1530, 1633-4 (H.S.P. 53) (1905): 122 (Owen pedigree)]. The name of Ellen's son was Thomas Gardiner. He was Prior of Tynemouth, Northumberland from 1528 to 1536.
The new account of Jasper Tudor in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, however, falls even further afield from the truth. Even through the author was surely aware of the above statement in the old DNB about Jasper Tudor's illegitimate daughter, the new ODNB states that Jasper Tudor "seems to have fathered no children, and the king was his heir." There is no mention whatsoever of an illegitimate daughter. The word "seems" is a poor choice of words, as it can be clearly demonstrated that (a) Jasper Tudor left no legitimate issue, and (b) that he had an illegitimate daughter, Ellen, who married William Gardiner.
For what it is worth, I'm finding repeated and often glaring genealogical errors in almost every account of the new ODNB. Genealogy is clearly the short suit of many modern historians.
Best always, Douglas Richardson, Salt Lake City, Utah
mjcar@btinternet.com - 30 Aug 2007 07:38 GMT > So, obviously, Mr. Gardiner, the author is not as astute as many on > this list and jumps (no, leaps) to many conclusions. Indeed, and as you suggest, many of them are widely faulty. For instance, trying to argue identity from the spelling of a name at a time when orthography was far from settled is not very convincing. Neither is identifying a man married in 1520 as a priest.
However, what Douglas has not done (apart from the possible Visitation reference, which I have not reviewed) is to cite anything remotely primary; his sources date from 1849 to 1972, although they deal with an individual who died in 1555.
It is worth noting the reasons behind ODNB's statement:
"[He] was born, according to John Bale, at Bury St Edmunds, and thus was probably the son of that name mentioned in the will of John Gardiner, a clothmaker from Bury, of 18 January 1507."
It therefore seems that it is not certain, as Douglas would have it, but merely a sound supposition that Gardiner's father was named John.
Regards, Michael
Douglas Richardson - 30 Aug 2007 18:31 GMT I'll repeat my statements one more time for simple emphasis: Complete Peerage has it wrong. Stephen Gardiner, Bishop of Winchester, was not the son of William Gardiner, of London, and his wife, Ellen Tudor. William and Ellen had only one son, Thomas, who was the Prior of Tynemouth, Northumberland.
Best always, Douglas Richardson
mjcar@btinternet.com - 30 Aug 2007 22:04 GMT > If anyone has furrther particulars of Ellen Tudor and William > Gardiner, or their issue, I'd very much appreciate hearing from them > here on the newsgroup. Dear Douglas
It might have been easier if you had indicated that you had other material, rather than post the later references; thank you for explaining this.
Ellen, the daughter of Jasper Tudor, married at least twice, as is detailed in the following PRO document:
"Peter Watson, of London, draper, and William Sybson, husband of Ellen, late the wife of William Gardyner v the Mayor, Aldermen, and Sheriffs of London: an action by the children of William Gardyner, deceased, to recover the portion of his son Thomas, who has entered Westminster abbey" (C 1/252/12, dated 1501-1502).
We also see from this that William Gardiner had "children", not just a son Thomas.
A further clue about this second marriage is provided in a second PRO document, this time dated to between 1486-1493:
"Thomas Dra...y, of London, mercer. v William Sibson, of London, skinner, and Elyn, his wife: debt for furs supplied to the said Elyn" (C 1/91/5).
This latter may assist in indicating the likely terminus ante quo for William Gardiner's death, and the date by which the Sibson marriage had taken place.
Regards, Michael
John Briggs - 31 Aug 2007 00:45 GMT >> If anyone has furrther particulars of Ellen Tudor and William >> Gardiner, or their issue, I'd very much appreciate hearing from them [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > deceased, to recover the portion of his son Thomas, who has entered > Westminster abbey" (C 1/252/12, dated 1501-1502). Tynemouth was also Benedictine, so it is likely that he has the right Thomas.
> We also see from this that William Gardiner had "children", not just a > son Thomas. At least three children, in fact, and the younger ones at least were minors in 1501-1502. At what age would you enter Westminster Abbey?
> A further clue about this second marriage is provided in a second PRO > document, this time dated to between 1486-1493: [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > William Gardiner's death, and the date by which the Sibson marriage > had taken place. It seems mildly odd that a Grocer's widow should marry a Skinner, if only to get furs...
 Signature John Briggs
|
|
|