History Forum / General / British History / July 2008

DSH
Lux et Veritas et Libertas
Vires et Honor

July 13, 2008

McCain's Conservative Model?  Roosevelt (Theodore, That Is)

By ADAM NAGOURNEY and MICHAEL COOPER
The New York Times

HUDSON, Wis. - Senator John McCain in a wide-ranging interview called for a
government that is frugal but more active than many conservatives might
prefer. He said government should play an important role in areas like
addressing climate change, regulating campaign finance and taking care of
"those in America who cannot take care of themselves."

"I count myself as a conservative Republican, yet I view it to a large
degree in the Theodore Roosevelt mold," Mr. McCain said, referring to
Roosevelt's reputation for reform, environmentalism and tough foreign
policy.

The views expressed by Mr. McCain in the 45-minute interview here Friday
illustrated the challenge the probable Republican presidential nominee faces
as he tries to navigate the sensibilities of his party's conservative base
and those of the moderate and independent voters he needs to defeat Senator
Barack Obama, his Democratic rival.

His responses suggested that he was basically in sync with his party's
conservative core but was not always willing to use the power of the federal
government to impose those values. He also expressed a willingness to deploy
government power and influence where free-market purists might hesitate to
do so and to consider unleashing military force for moral reasons.

In recent weeks, Mr. McCain has left many Republicans unsettled about his
ideological bearings by toggling between reliably conservative issues like
support for gun owners' rights and an emphasis on centrist messages like his
willingness to tackle global warming and provide a path to citizenship for
illegal immigrants.

Those tensions were apparent in the interview as well, as Mr. McCain offered
a variety of answers - sometimes nuanced in their phrasing, sometimes not -
about his views on social issues.

Mr. McCain, who with his wife, Cindy, has an adopted daughter, said flatly
that he opposed allowing gay couples to adopt. "I think that we've proven
that both parents are important in the success of a family so, no, I don't
believe in gay adoption," he said.

But he declined to take a specific position when asked whether only
evolution should be taught in public schools. "It's up to the school
boards," he said. "That's why we have local control over education." Mr.
McCain has said he believes in evolution.

Many social conservatives strenuously oppose California's decision to allow
same-sex marriage. But Mr. McCain, who also opposes same-sex marriage, has
always said that the issue is up to the states, and in the interview he said
he would stick to that position as president even if California chose to
continue allowing gay marriage after putting the matter to a statewide vote
in November. "I respect the right of the states to make those decisions," he
said.

Asked if he considered himself an evangelical Christian, Mr. McCain
responded, "I consider myself a Christian."

"I attend church," he said. "My faith has sustained me in very difficult
times." Asked how often he attended, he responded: "Not as often as I
should." He has recently been photographed going to church as his campaign
has begun to make public the times he attends services.

Mr. McCain sat down for the interview, conducted after he held a
town-hall-style meeting on economic issues, at the end of a week that his
campaign had hoped would mark a turning point in a candidacy that has been
plagued with missteps and often seemed unsure of its message.

After a period in which his campaign again endured internal battling and
staff upheaval, Mr. McCain argued that competing tensions in an
organization - be it a presidential campaign or a White House - can be good
thing, up to a point.

"Because of the bubble that a president is in, and the bubble that a
candidate is in, sometimes you find out afterwards something that, 'Oh boy,
I wish I had heard thus and such and so and so,' " he said. "So I appreciate
and want some of the tension. I don't want too much of it."

When asked if he felt that it was more difficult to run against Mr. Obama
because of the sensitivities of race, Mr. McCain responded wryly: "I'd like
to make a joke, but I can't."

"We are in a situation today where all words are parsed, all comments are
diagnosed and looked at for whatever effect they might have," he said. "We
have to feed the beast, the hourly cable shows, the instant news in the
blogs and all that. That is just the situation that we're in, and I'm not
complaining about it, because that would be both foolish and a waste of
time."

Mr. McCain went on to say that he did not consider running against Mr. Obama
any more complicated than running against, say, Senator Hillary Rodham
Clinton. "No, I have to base my approach to Senator Obama as one of
respect," he said. "As long as I do that, then I don't have to worry about
any language I might use."

He said, ruefully, that he had not mastered how to use the Internet and
relied on his wife and aides like Mark Salter, a senior adviser, and Brooke
Buchanan, his press secretary, to get him online to read newspapers (though
he prefers reading those the old-fashioned way) and political Web sites and
blogs.

"They go on for me," he said. "I am learning to get online myself, and I
will have that down fairly soon, getting on myself. I don't expect to be a
great communicator, I don't expect to set up my own blog, but I am becoming
computer literate to the point where I can get the information that I need."

Asked which blogs he read, he said: "Brooke and Mark show me Drudge,
obviously. Everybody watches, for better or for worse, Drudge. Sometimes I
look at Politico. Sometimes RealPolitics."

At that point, Mrs. McCain, who had been intensely engaged with her
BlackBerry, looked up and chastised her husband. "Meghan's blog!" she said,
reminding him of their daughter's blog on his campaign Web site. "Meghan's
blog," he said sheepishly.

As he answered questions, sipping a cup of coffee with his tie tight around
his neck, his aides stared down at their BlackBerries.

As they tapped, Mr. McCain said he did not use a BlackBerry, though he
regularly reads messages on those of his aides. "I don't e-mail, I've never
felt the particular need to e-mail," Mr. McCain said.

The interview underscored the extent to which Mr. McCain defies easy
ideological characterization, a fact that might help him in a general
election but has been a persistent cause of concern among some
conservatives. Mr. McCain has long argued that his stances are evidence of
his political independence; many of his critics say it is more an example of
a politician deftly trying to shade positions to win an election in
complicated electoral terrain.

Mr. McCain said he believed that the United States government had an
obligation to intervene to stop genocide, though only if it was clear that a
solution was possible. Mr. McCain also said that the Federal Reserve was
right to step in during the collapse of the investment firm Bear Stearns,
and that he would similarly support some sort of aggressive action to avert
a meltdown of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the nation's two largest mortgage
finance companies, should that prove necessary.

"I don't know if a government, quote, bailout is necessary now," he said.
"Because there are other courses of action that are being explored in order
to ensure their survival. But I don't believe we can afford to have them
fail, because of their impact on the overall economy."

Asked to name a conservative model, he skipped over the suggestions of three
names typically associated with the conservative movement - Ronald Reagan,
George W. Bush and Barry Goldwater, the founder of the modern-day
conservative movement who occupied the Senate seat Mr. McCain holds today -
to settle on Theodore Roosevelt.

Mr. McCain has long admired Roosevelt, and in the interview he identified
with him as a fellow reformer and environmentalist and also touched on his
assertive foreign policy. The choice might to some extent be an indication
of how Mr. McCain would like to position himself now that he has moved from
the primary to the general election.

"I believe less governance is the best governance, and that government
should not do what the free enterprise and private enterprise and individual
entrepreneurship and the states can do, but I also believe there is a role
for government," Mr. McCain said. He added: "Government should take care of
those in America who can not take care of themselves."