That's a VERY interesting summary ---- even profound.
This sounds JUST like a personality sketch of P. Jonathan Gans, our
radical-chic, Greenwich-Village Marxist and parlor-socialist Left-Wing
chemist at NYU ---- [Yes, he has proven himself to be all of those, in
spades.].
In fact the summary fits him like a glove.
Who is Richard H. Shulman? He's bright.
D. Spencer Hines
Lux et Veritas et Libertas
Vires et Honor
"TonyaK9" <TonK911@excite.com> wrote in message
news:bFURb.859$F23.575@newsread2.news.pas.earthlink.net...
| Translation: Kook is lost, he's got no real rebuttal to my post and is
| desperately trying to save his face.
|
| Here is an interesting re-post of an article written some 6 years ago,
with
| yet another take on the subject.
|
| Let's see if our readers can draw any historical parallels between the
| Russian/German Self-hating Jews and Chomskian crowd:
|
| Ricshulman (ricshulman@aol.com) Date: 1997/06/02
|
| 6/2/97 ARAB-ISRAEL CONFLICT 608: Self-Hating Jews Explained
|
| Here is a 1 1/2 page synopsis of an enlightening but controversial
| explanation of the phenomenon. The syndrome arose relatively
recently -- in
| the last century.
|
| Self-hating Jews do not feel rooted in anything Jewish, neither
religion nor
| nationality. Many of these "non-Jewish Jews" also are alienated from
the
| gentile society in which they reside. They challenge the values and
| natural and religious identity both of Jews and non-Jews. The fact
that
| this challenge does not emanate from Judaism is lost upon the
gentiles.
| Gentiles direct their anger against all Jews.
|
| The proportion of Jews who are radicals is small, but the proportion
of
| radicals who are Jews is noticeably large. Jews have a tradition of
| challenging values. Although the radicals denigrate tradition, the
| traditional habit of challenging values got passed down to them.
Since they
| are rootless, they become revolutionaries and try to alienate
everybody
| from their roots, so they won't be so different form other people.
| Participation
| in international Socialism or Communism was a way of assimilating into
a
| universalist, non-Jewish world, where they thought they would be
accepted.
| Actually, they were not accepted even there.
|
| Feeling no kinship to any nation, these radicals ignored the
consequences
| of their movement. One consequence was increased anti-Semitism.
The
| Russians and Ukrainians identified Marxism with Jewry. During the
| Bolshevik Revolution, anti Communist Ukrainians murdered 50,000
Ukrainian
| Jews. Their infamous Gen. Petlura referred to "the Jew Trotsky."
|
| Ironically, Trotsky had no feeling for the Jewish people. Leon
Trotsky
| (nee Bronstein) refused to help Jews suffering from the civil war
pogroms.
| Moscow's Chief Rabbi told him, "The Trotskys make the revolutions and
the
| Bronsteins pay the price."
|
| Bolshevik victory didn't help the non-Jewish Jews, because
Leninism
| held that the Jewish nation should disappear through assimilation.
Thus
| these Communist Jews served to help position Communist anti-Semitism,
which
| eventually turned on them.
|
| Jewish radicals influenced the cultural life of the Weimar
Republic
| disproportionately. German gentiles resented this. A leading
non-Jewish
| Jewish intellectual magazine, Die Weltbuhne, indiscriminately attacked
| German culture and national life. Its editor once wrote, "This country
...is
| not my country; this state is not my state; this legal system is not
my
| legal system. Its different banners are to me as meaningless as are
its
| provincial
| ideals... We are traitors."
|
| The same editor "abominated the majority of his fellow citizens.
Princes,
| barons, Junkers, officers, policemen, judges, officials, clergymen,
| academicians, teachers, capitalists, burgers, university students,
peasants
| and all barbarians..."
|
| In 1932, alienated German Jews likened Zionism to Nazism, thinking
| themselves progressive for doing so.
|
| Some of the left-wing criticisms were reasonable, but their overall
attacks
| were perceived as destructive.
|
| In the US, the non-Jewish Jews form a major part of the radical left,
| hostile to everything American and drawing resentment down on Jewry as
a
| whole. Jews formed a major part of US Communist Party in the 1930s and
| 1940s.
|
| Example: I.F. Stone (whom I remember as a fellow-traveler). The
overwhelming
| proportion of his essays attack American policy. Few defend anything
| American. After 1976, he used to claim that he reports the Arab side,
| because the US press is overwhelmingly pro-Zionist, long a theme of
| anti-Semites. He asserted a duty to tell the truth, but the truth is
that
| the media hardly told the Israeli side after 1967.
|
| A majority of US TV producers and writers are Jewish. They hold
religion as
| trivial or sinister, that power brokers are bad or irrelevant, that
| criminals are not responsible for crimes, and that the middle class
are
| fools. They subvert our culture, because their real target is not
some
| inequity but the social order (Dennis Prager, Ultimate Issues
magazine,
| 1988).
|
| Richard H. Shulman
D. Spencer Hines - 28 Jan 2004 15:24 GMT
| Freud, as I stated, would piss all over this Self-Hating Jew crap.
Pogue Cook
----------------------
Pogue Cook [that's Michael W. Cook of London] is so stupid and
pig-ignorant he doesn't realize that SIGMUND FREUD [1856-1939] was one
of the PRINCIPAL DEVELOPERS and INVESTIGATORS of the concept of the
Self-Hating Jew.
Pogue Cook is stupider than a coprolite ---- but similar in substance.
Pogue Cook needs to initiate his basic studies in psychoanalysis by
reading Sigmund Freud's famous _Dora_ case study [Fragment of an
analysis of a case of hysteria -- 1905.] -- and he should scribble and
prattle no more codswallop on this subject on USENET until he has done
so.
Freud had a PROFOUND understanding of the Self-Hating Jew.
Here's an excellent analysis of the Dora Case by Michael Billig, a
British Social Psychologist.
http://www.massey.ac.nz/~alock/virtual/dora4.htm
And A Peek:
"Freud and Dora: repressing an oppressed identity"
["How is the desire to assimilate related to 'self-hatred'?"]
"Hannah Arendt (1970) described the Jews of Germany as having an
unrequited love affair with German culture.
The tragedy for such Jews was that the culture, which they embraced so
passionately, was routinely anti-semitic.
The same was true for the German speaking Jews of the Austro-Hungarian
Empire. Those, who were enthusiastic to be culturally German, adopted
many of that culture's prejudices against things Jewish. The bourgeois,
assimilating Jews directed these prejudices against the ghetto Jews of
the eastern Europe, the Ostjuden, who displayed overt, and shameful,
characteristics of Jewishness (Weitzmann, 1987).
Jokes about Jewish dress, meanness and unclean habits were common:
'dirty-Jew' jokes were to find their way into Freud's _Jokes and their
Relation to the Unconscious_. A brittle and painful constellation of
feelings was involved: the desire to be German, the separation from
Jewishness, the association of Jewishness with despised traits, and a
recognition that the true Germans would still see Jewishness in
themselves, despite all their efforts. At its extreme, this
constellation formed the basis of what has become known as
'self-hatred'."
- from Freud and Dora: repressing an oppressed identity, by Michael
Billig, Department of Social Sciences, University of Loughborough.
Published in the British Journal of Social Psychology
--------------------------------------------------------
This Pogue Cook, the London guttersnipe, university dropout and obscene,
vicious, scruffy little Anti-Semite, is REALLY IGNORANT, Virginia. He
absolutely WALLOWS in a SLOUGH of Ignorance ---- yet he POSTS ----
lying, obscene gibberish.
He also just LOVES to write degrading and obscene posts, particularly to
and about Jewish Women, posts such as this one:
| Hilarious.
|
| Delusions of grandeur from the intellectually bankrupt K9.
|
| Best she goes back to licking her own arse.
-------------------------------------------
Or This One:
"From: Michael W Cook (crusader_productions@hotmail.com)
Subject: Re: Defending the Indefensible
View: Complete Thread (109 articles)
Newsgroups: alt.history.british, sci.military.naval, soc.culture.israel,
soc.culture.jewish, soc.history.medieval, soc.culture.palestine
Date: 2004-01-23 15:00:44 PST
in article bus5vu$jgt27$1@ID-205389.news.uni-berlin.de, Ariel at
arielv2@37.com wrote on 23/1/04 10:10 pm:
> ran out of arguments , cook?
> typical nazi....
I don't argue with Tonka, I just abuse her for her Nazi-like Jewish
expansionist views and the racial hatred she directs at Arabs. She isn't
capable of entering into a serious discussion, I learnt that several
years ago.
In fact, it's perfectly clear that Tonka is in need of a damn good f.ck,
up the arse would be best, then hopefully it would shut her up for a
while.
The problem is, there's not a man on this earth who would do it.
What's your excuse ?
Or is it that you're just another thick-as-sh.t Zionist like Goldman,
who hasn't the intelligence to write more than two or three lines at the
most ?
I'd run along back to the pack if I were you. You've won your bronze
star for managing to get in the Nazi accusation - applause all round for
you tomorrow at prayers. Next time go for the full award and see if you
can get Jew hater, anti-Semite and Bigot in there as well.
You can rest assured I won't be bothering to read or answer it.
-------------------------------------
Cook = Pond Scum...Of The Lowest Possible Grade....
Pure & Simple....
You'll notice I've SHAMED Pogue Cook into NOT using such obscene,
abusive language to Tonka LATELY. Vide infra.
Will he still use it when responding to Goldman?
Throughout all this, GANS, Cook's Lord & Master, our Left-Wing NYU
chemist, has cowered in the corner and been afraid to confront Cook
publicly ---- condemning Cook on his gross, degrading obscenities and
vicious Anti-Semitism.
Bad Show....
Gans = Craven Coward
I'm simply DELIGHTED to see that Pogue Cook has [at least currently]
focused all his virulent hatred and rage on ME ---- and is NOT abusing,
insulting and posting obscene lies about Susan Cohen, TK 9 and other
good folks in these newsgroups ---- folks who just happen to be Jewish.
That's PRECISELY what I WANTED to happen.
Many here, including Cook's Lord & Master, P. Jonathan Gans, the
Left-Wing NYU chemist, are just too damned cowardly to do that.
If I have to take some vicious, obscene flack from Pogue Cook, because I
condemned his actions publicly, so be it.
These shoulders can take the load ---- and I'm not afraid of the
vicious, obscene little London guttersnipe.
Obviously, many others here ARE afraid of Cook ---- and take the
attitude of ---- "Well, he's not attacking ME! Why should I sweat it."
Lest We Forget:
-------------------------
"First they came for the Communists,
and I didn't speak up,
because I wasn't a Communist.
Then they came for the Jews,
and I didn't speak up,
because I wasn't a Jew.
Then they came for the Catholics,
and I didn't speak up,
because I was a Protestant.
Then they came for me,
and by that time there was no one
left to speak up for me."
----------------------------
The Reverend. Martin Niemoller, 1945
Deus Vult
Sholem Aleichem
D. Spencer Hines
Lux et Veritas et Libertas
Vires et Honor
[...]
| Freud, as I stated, would piss all over this Self-Hating Jew crap.
|
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
|
| MWC
Michael W Cook - 28 Jan 2004 22:36 GMT
> That's a VERY interesting summary ---- even profound.
Idiotic more like it.
There is NO such thing as a Self-Hating Jew.
It's an extreme Zionist label for someone Jewish who criticises Israel.
"You do not agree with my politics, therefore you are a Self-hating Jew."
Freud would piss all over it.
MWC
U840@sbcglobal.net - 29 Jan 2004 23:59 GMT
> > That's a VERY interesting summary ---- even profound.
>
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> MWC
This is a very good comment. It is verbal judo to say someone is self hating
if they question some element of group think belief - wouldn't the current
leaders of the power structure of the group love that to be true.