I recently read that some AIDS researchers are studying people whose
ancestors survived the 14th century bubonic plague.
Is it true that studying that plague might help in fighting AIDS?
Is it not possible that people survived the plague because of random
chance and not genes. When those fleas are jumping around it's just
the luck of the draw.
Madhusudan Singh - 02 Jun 2004 21:51 GMT
> I recently read that some AIDS researchers are studying people whose
> ancestors survived the 14th century bubonic plague.
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> chance and not genes. When those fleas are jumping around it's just
> the luck of the draw.
Not necessarily. Some people have better resistance to certain diseases than
others. That is how natural selection works.
Silentotto - 03 Jun 2004 00:13 GMT
> I recently read that some AIDS researchers are studying people whose
> ancestors survived the 14th century bubonic plague.
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> chance and not genes. When those fleas are jumping around it's just
> the luck of the draw.
They're not trying to study people who managed to avoid the plague.
They're trying to study people who contracted the plague and somehow
survived.
Certainly luck could be a factor in their survival, but we know from
studying other diseases that a certain percentage of individuals, be
they mice, men or bacteria tend to have increased resistance or
immunity from what ever happens to be going around.
When a disease has as high mortaliaty rate as the plague did, it makes
sence to study those who managed to survive the disease for clues as
to why they survived.
Such clues could provide a means of prevention or a cure.
Robert - 29 Jun 2004 07:50 GMT
> I recently read that some AIDS researchers are studying people whose
> ancestors survived the 14th century bubonic plague.
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> chance and not genes. When those fleas are jumping around it's just
> the luck of the draw.
You guys are close but no cigar. Where are all the immunologist at?
The plague is a bacteria that binds to the same receptor that the HIV virus
binds to. I believe that is the P24 antigen found in CD4 cells. These
antigens are determined genetically. If you do not have the receptor or
antigen you can not get HIV. People who lacked that antigen during the
plaque years did not get sick. There are cluster communities in Europe in
which survivors have passed on the genes. Like most genes there is a
heterozygous state and homozygous state.